• There seems to be an uptick in Political comments in recent months. Those of us who are long time members of the site know that Political and Religious content has been banned for years. Nothing has changed. Please leave all political and religious comments out of the forums.

    If you recently joined the forums you were not presented with this restriction in the terms of service. This was due to a conversion error when we went from vBulletin to Xenforo. We have updated our terms of service to reflect these corrections.

    Please note any post refering to a politician will be considered political even if it is intended to be humor. Our experience is these topics have a way of dividing the forums and causing deep resentment among members. It is a poison to the community. We appreciate compliance with the rules.

    The Staff of SOH

  • Server side Maintenance is done. We still have an update to the forum software to run but that one will have to wait for a better time.

MV DHC-2 Update AND Expansion Pack RELEASED

cavaricooper

cavaricooper

SOH-CM-2023
Installing as I write, very hopeful the FDE has been worked on.... It would make me very happy to have a psuedo GA replacement for my Annuschka in v4.... fingers 'xed!

She looks GOOD with her STOL kit on.....

c47EdWj.jpg


Off to see how she FLIES.....

Best- C
 
This is FANTASTIC news!!! Now repainting of the Beaver can finally begin in earnest... except that the new paintkit is "Temporarily Unavailable"!

Andy
 
The old paintkit had to be pulled from the product page; as soon as the new one finds a home on the server the link will be back!
 
cavaricooper said:
Installing as I write, very hopeful the FDE has been worked on.... It would make me very happy to have a psuedo GA replacement for my Annuschka in v4.... fingers 'xed!

She looks GOOD with her STOL kit on.....

Off to see how she FLIES.....

Best- C
Click to expand...

LOL, You are really fast man to check this release :) .

Yes, this is new STOL version (the main difference is on front of wings):

ExPackDHC_qhpnwes.jpg


ExPackDHC_qhpnwnq.jpg


ExPackDHC_qhpnweh.jpg
 
cavaricooper said:
Installing as I write, very hopeful the FDE has been worked on.... It would make me very happy to have a psuedo GA replacement for my Annuschka in v4.... fingers 'xed!

She looks GOOD with her STOL kit on.....

c47EdWj.jpg


Off to see how she FLIES.....

Best- C
Click to expand...

Carl,

Thanks for the heads up! I won't be able to try her until later tonight, so be sure to update us with your thoughts!
:ernaehrung004:
 
So, are there any noticeable changes to the FDE? I just bought the pack as well, but won't be able to play with it until Sunday at the earliest...


Andrew Entwistle
 
cavaricooper said:
Installing as I write, very hopeful the FDE has been worked on.... It would make me very happy to have a psuedo GA replacement for my Annuschka in v4.... fingers 'xed!

She looks GOOD with her STOL kit on.....

c47EdWj.jpg


Off to see how she FLIES.....

Best- C
Click to expand...

Cavaricooper, I've seen your many posts about the FDE and your comparison with the An-2. I also have the Annoushka and indeed it is amazing. However, it is a biplane, even if a huge one. The Beaver is a more solid flying aeroplane having full span flaps that are used even for cruising. Do not expect to get the same "feel" flying the Beaver as with the Antonov. I have never flown a real Beaver, my only real taildragger experience is the SuperCub, and the MV Beaver feels like a heavy Cub. Tom, on the other side, the FDE developer, has huge numbers of hours on all types of Beavers as well as making FDEs so I tend to trust him. What may not feel right to someone does not mean it is not correct.
 
Several queries about the FDE, with no (or non) responses. Is this a case of "if you can't say anything nice..."? ;-)

I'll give MV not quite a swing and a miss at this update... but maybe a swing and a double. There's slight improvement, but the problem is not solved.

The problem being the behavior of the tail on the ground, and its response to elevator inputs. I've never flown a Beaver either, but I've flown similar sized taildraggers, and things still don't seem quite right. This is further supported by video evidence and what I see on a regular basis. Even in a light airplane with a full forward cg and full down elevator held throughout the takeoff roll, the Milviz Beaver won't lift her tail until around 45mph - the point at which she's ready to fly anyway. And it comes up slooooowly then. I've been linking the same video as an example in all these discussions, so I'll show a different one this time - the popular Harrison Ford film "Just Another Pilot". Watch the takeoff at around 1:25. If anyone can replicate that performance of the tail aggressively popping off the ground just a couple seconds into the roll, I'd love to know how:
https://youtu.be/QsgiEubacT0

The problem seems to me to remain the same - propwash is not modeled. The head honcho over on the MV forums scoffed at me for pointing out that other developers have been able to model this accurately, noting "we're not doing accusim here for this price". Considering the base price of this plane plus the expansion puts it well into accusimmed territory, I had higher hopes for the FDE tweaks, personally.

It does feel to me that there's been some improvement. This is all subjective, but I do feel the tail comes up slightly better than before on takeoff, and I'm confident it's easier to hold the tail up after a wheel landing. So clearly MV listened and responded and I commend them for that. I just don't think they're *quite* there yet.

Haven't played with the add on models yet, though I expect I'll pick that package up at some point. This certainly remains one of the best bush planes currently available for fsx/p3d.

YMMV but that's my take. I'm interested to hear other's thoughts.
 
stearmandriver said:
The problem seems to me to remain the same - propwash is not modeled. The head honcho over on the MV forums scoffed at me for pointing out that other developers have been able to model this accurately, noting "we're not doing accusim here for this price". Considering the base price of this plane plus the expansion puts it well into accusimmed territory, I had higher hopes for the FDE tweaks, personally.
Click to expand...
You definitely don't need acccusim for this as FSX does model propwash. E.g. the updated Flight Replicas Super Cub can do brake stand take-offs.
 
Dimus said:
Cavaricooper, I've seen your many posts about the FDE and your comparison with the An-2. I also have the Annoushka and indeed it is amazing. However, it is a biplane, even if a huge one. The Beaver is a more solid flying aeroplane having full span flaps that are used even for cruising. Do not expect to get the same "feel" flying the Beaver as with the Antonov. I have never flown a real Beaver, my only real taildragger experience is the SuperCub, and the MV Beaver feels like a heavy Cub. Tom, on the other side, the FDE developer, has huge numbers of hours on all types of Beavers as well as making FDEs so I tend to trust him. What may not feel right to someone does not mean it is not correct.
Click to expand...


+1 2 completely different aircraft, they may have been designed for the same purpose however its like trying to compare a Swordfish to a Corsair or even a Hellcat
 
@Dimus- Absolutely agree!

I am NOT looking for similar flight characteristics. I AM LOOKING for the transmittal of the feel of flight and similar SATISFACTION after spending a couple of hours in the VC. Like you, I have never flown the Beaver, but I have flown (and owned) many different aircraft (mostly tail-draggers) and know what I am looking for.... I am hoping to experience the sensation of flight once more, albeit from a desk. I did not comment further on the FDE, as I fully appreciate all the work that goes on behind an upgrade, on what is a beautiful aircraft indeed. What I want is very personal, and since leaving v3 and the Annuschka behind.... I continue my search. BTW- your Locher work looks superb!


@ALL-
If the FR Super Cub works in Prepar3d v4 please do let me know asap, I so miss my low and slow flightings. Bernt's FDEs are amongst the very best, and I would love something that he worked on.....

Now- Back to the thread... the Beaver update...

Best- Carl
 
Agree with you fully on the FR SuperCub and Bernt's FDE. I have not yet tried it in V4.

Locher is expected in September after my return. Thanks for the kind words! The STOL Beaver would be great for it although I don't think any Beavers fly in the area.
 
In Tongass Fjords area of FSAddon (P3Dv4).
Natural environment of Beavers! ;)

ExPackDHC_qhpsaep.jpg


STOL+cargo.

rescue-beaver-tail-orphan-canada-3.gif
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top